This forum is in permanent archive mode. Our new active community can be found here.

Verizon and alt.*

RymRym
edited June 2008 in Technology
Usenet is an ancient system, reliant upon archaic and inefficient technology, that is used by a small minority of Internet users yet accounts for massive amounts of bandwidth and disproportionate support costs.

In order to properly process the raw news feeds, a server must be extremely powerful and have a very large pipe. (I'm not going to bother explaining the reasons for this, aside from the fact that the protocols involved are almost entirely useless in the modern age). As such, ISPs that support it will provide these servers for their users, effectively replicating all of Usenet locally.

As you can imagine, offering this service is very expensive. Despite this, there is nothing at all to be gained from doing so. There are commercial providers out there that offer Usenet access for the extreme minority of Internet users who desire it (for a fee), and no one else cares.

Now, there are two major misconceptions about all of this. Namely, that Verizon is dropping all of Usenet, and that they are somehow blocking access to it entirely. I point out the following:
  1. Verizon is only dropping alt.*
  2. Verizon is NOT blocking ANYTHING
Let's address the first point. Verizon is only dropping ONE of the nine real Usenet hierarchies: alt.*. They are still carrying the rest. If Usenet is a giant waste of bandwidth and server resources, then alt.* accounts for a full 99% of that waste, particularly alt.binaries. This is some four Terrabytes of data per day. There are eight "official" Usenet hierarchies, which are administered by the Big Eight Management Board: comp.*, misc.*, news.*, rec.*, sci.*, soc.*, and talk.*, and Verizon is clearly continuing to carry them. Alt.* is completely unadministered.

As for the second point, VERIZON ISN'T BLOCKING ANYTHING. NOTHING AT ALL.

All Verizon has done is drop their own, optional, consensual, local hosting of alt.*. Anyone is free to access alt.* in any way they wish: Verizon just won't go out and get it all for them anymore.

Comments

  • Thank you, some nice information I didn't bump into yesterday in a quick wiki search. One note, you forgot humanities.* as one of the big 8.
  • I like the new front page of that website:
    Important Notice for Verizon Customers

    You have not received any e-mail from the Big-8 Management Board.

    We are not responsible in any way for Verizon's decision to carry only Big-8 newsgroups.

    Please do not complain to us about Verizon's decision to carry only Big-8 newsgroups. We had nothing to do with it, and we can't do anything about it. If you wish to complain, please contact Verizon.

    If you wish to find out what the Big-8 is and how it is different from the alt.* hierarchy, please click here to proceed to our Web site.
    Martin X. Moleski, SJ
    co-chair, b8mb
    June 17, 2008
  • Many Thanks Rym.
  • thank you for the clarification.
  • I believe Google Groups also doesn't carry alt.binaries. Funnily enough, I was just reading through some old posts on alt.atheism today...
Sign In or Register to comment.