This forum is in permanent archive mode. Our new active community can be found here.

Which MLP:FIM Pony is the Best?

1356714

Comments

  • Rainbow Dash is not gay. You can clearly see a the end of the newest episodes that she flies off with two male Wonderbolts.
    To have sex, clearly.

    If it was for any reason other than this then you're wrong. You're still wrong. Nothing wrong with testing the waters on the other side sometimes. (:
  • How am I the only one that voted for Fluttershy? She's so cute and adorable!
  • How am I the only one that voted for Fluttershy? She's so cute and adorable!
    I like Fluttershy and her cuteness, but not the best character by far.
  • Pinkie Pie is clearly living the existentialist dream. Or Camus has polluted more than just Literature class.
  • At least I have one brother in my love of Applejack.
  • edited February 2011
    Whoa, I just woke up and it's already at 67 posts! This forum is awesome.
    Rainbow Dash was clearly going to win, and that's who I voted for, but I feel sorry for Fluttershy at only 1 vote :(
    Post edited by lackofcheese on
  • edited February 2011
    I love her and her love of animals, but she is too much of a helicopter (bunny) mom.

    Edit: Also, was there something about animals in Ponyville not being able to take care of themselves? They were like freaked out that animals in the forest didn't need guardians. I guess Fluttershy gets a pass.
    Post edited by gomidog on
  • At least I have one brother in my love of Applejack.
    Applejack for life yo.
  • I voted for Rarity. She tempers the fact that she's a greedy, vain, snobbish gold-digger with being patient, generous, and having genuine, practical talent. She also steals from dragons and I like her color scheme the best.
  • Rarity is pretty hard to like for most of the latest epsiode, though.
  • edited February 2011
    How am I the only one that voted for Fluttershy? She's so cute and adorable!
    The problem is that the poll is asking the best/most awesome pony. If it was favorite pony, I'd vote Fluttershy in a heartbeat.
    Post edited by Linkigi(Link-ee-jee) on
  • Also, was there something about animals in Ponyville not being able to take care of themselves? They were like freaked out that animals in the forest didn't need guardians. I guess Fluttershy gets a pass.
    Recall that the pegasus ponies completely control the weather in all the pony villages and cities. They have largely conquered all of nature within their lands.

    Outside of the principality, there is a natural order that, for whatever reason, they long ago forsook.
  • I feel bad for Spike. I bet no one likes him. Also, I love Pinkie Pie for this reason too.
  • edited February 2011
    I feel bad for Spike. I bet no one likes him. Also, I love Pinkie Pie for this reason too.


    Spike is not a part of this discussion, we are solely speaking of ponies.
    Post edited by Hitman Hart on
  • The ℳℴℯ one. I'm kind of a sucker for cute shy girls ponies who love animals.
  • Why is there no love for Big Macintosh? He's obviously the coolest pony in the entire freaking show!
  • There are many votes that are not yet in, but I think it is safe to crown the winner.
  • Yay Rainbow Dash!
  • Got kind of old on the third repetition, but thanks for making that, Scott.
  • Got kind of old on the third repetition,
    That's what she said.
  • Got kind of old on the third repetition, but thanks for making that, Scott.
    Yeah. I couldn't decide how many repeats was the right number.
  • edited February 2011
    Even though the winner's already been crowned, I voted anyway just to see if I could pin down a favourite. The fact that making a choice was so hard really speaks to the likeability of the whole cast. Everypony should be lauded for that, I think. Well, except Celestia, whom nobody likes, apparently.

    I started with a five-way tie between Twilight, Rainbow, Fluttershy, Applejack, and Apple Bloom, and eventually forced myself to whittle it down to just Fluttershy and Applejack. Fluttershy I like for being adorable to the max, kind, nurturing, pretty in pink, flight-capable, and having balls when it really counts (see: Pilot Pt. 2; Dragonshy). Applejack I like for being hard-working, feisty, athletic, strongly opinionated, having a cute hat and hair ties, and always making me crave apples and/or apple juice when she's onscreen. In the end, this tipped the scale in Fluttershy's favour for me:



    The whole Flutterguy thing was probably some of the funniest shit in the series for me.

    Anyway, I'll still concede that Rainbow Dash is objectively at least 20% cooler than any other pony, and I like her loads too. I just leaned towards some of the others more personally.

    (Also, if Spike had been qualified? I would've voted for him. Hands down. I love a good deadpan snarker.)
    Post edited by Eryn on
  • The whole Flutterguy thing was probably some of the funniest shit in the series for me.
    Hehehe....
  • I still love Pinkie's "come at me bro" pose.
  • As much as I understand why everyone is obsessed with this show, I don't get it.
  • As much as I understand why everyone is obsessed with this show, I don't get it.
    Did you watch it?
  • I don't get it.
    I think you want to italicize "I."
  • I still stand by my reasoning that Pinkie Pie is the Mihoshi of the show. Secret genius.
Sign In or Register to comment.