If it were cute dolphins spreading Malaria and biting, and the ecologists said it was ok, would you guys still be in favor of genocide?
Absolutely. Malaria kills about a million people every year, mostly children, and at this rate the deaths could double within the next 20 years. I'd much rather kill the cute dolphins and save the cute African kids.
Nuke the fuckers and keep their embryos cloned and on ice. Just like smallpox and the Spanish Flu.
Dolphins are also a ridiculous analogy. Like Luke said, they're borderline self-aware. Also, they experience emotions. Mosquitos are just flying syringes that spread like viruses and work on a purely self-serving instinct. All of their predators have greater food sources. We would lose nothing; keeping their genetics around would only be good for building massive vaccine delivery systems in genomically-sterilized mosquitoes.
If it were cute dolphins spreading Malaria and biting, and the ecologists said it was ok, would you guys still be in favor of genocide?
The problem with this question is, dolphins are not equivalent. There are not billions of them, they don't fly and get to you anywhere you are. If Dolphins spread Malaria and bite you we would treat them like sharks. If there was billions of them and they flew, we would be super screwed.
The thought of something the size of a dolphin flying up to me to bite me, or as part of a swarm...I'd say kill them all if something that big tried to land on me and bite me, I don't care how cute it acts...
So what's the word on fleas and ticks? Are those necessary, or can we wipe them from existence along with the mosquitoes?
Is ecology understood well enough to do this? We all hate mosquitoes but, really is this a good thing to do? Don't they carry parasites themselves which would then release it into another species because they don't exist to carry it? Just a weird thought.
Is ecology understood well enough to do this? We all hate mosquitoes but, really is this a good thing to do? Don't they carry parasites themselves which would then release it into another species because they don't exist to carry it? Just a weird thought.
NO MORE QUESTIONS! BURN THEMS! BURN THEMS ALL!!! MUAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Is ecology understood well enough to do this? We all hate mosquitoes but, really is this a good thing to do? Don't they carry parasites themselves which would then release it into another species because they don't exist to carry it? Just a weird thought.
Parasites are quite finicky. They're so highly co-evolved to suit their vectors and hosts that any disruption royally fucks the species, since they have no alternative niche to fit. If you want an interesting read on the subject, I recommend Carl Zimmer's Parasite Rex. It gives some fascinating insight into how parasites work and effective methods of dealing with them.
Comments
Dolphins are also a ridiculous analogy. Like Luke said, they're borderline self-aware. Also, they experience emotions. Mosquitos are just flying syringes that spread like viruses and work on a purely self-serving instinct. All of their predators have greater food sources. We would lose nothing; keeping their genetics around would only be good for building massive vaccine delivery systems in genomically-sterilized mosquitoes.
What a flying Dolphin might look like.
So what's the word on fleas and ticks? Are those necessary, or can we wipe them from existence along with the mosquitoes?