This forum is in permanent archive mode. Our new active community can be found here.

Which MLP:FIM Pony is the Best?

1679111214

Comments

  • Mission Complete

    image
  • edited March 2011
    Rym, here's a new desktop for you:
    image
    Post edited by Neito on
  • Rym, here's a new desktop for you:
    image
    That's mine.
  • image

    Today is Pinkie Pi day, so all glory to this Pink Pony Proletariat.
  • It's so hard to choose a pony to by MY little pony. I love Rarity, Pinkie, Twilight and Fluttershy equally. It's just TOO hard!
  • I threw in a vote for Pinkie Pie. Her Zecora song will always be stuck in my head.
  • It's so hard to choose a pony to by MY little pony. I love Rarity, Pinkie, Twilight and Fluttershy equally. It's just TOO hard!
    Here, I'll help. Just vote for Fluttershy. She's the moe to your Tsundere/yandere strangeness.
  • I threw in a vote for Pinkie Pie. Her Zecora song will always be stuck in my head.
    image

    Tru Dat
  • The Flutterguy version is funnier.
  • The Flutterguy version is funnier.
  • Okay, so I'm really starting to get into this now. Why are people voting for anypony other than Rainbow Dash?
  • The Flutterguy version is funnier.
    Not only is Flutterguy version funnier, it's better and clearly the song was meant for Flutterguy, story reasons needed the Pinkie Pie version there also.
    Okay, so I'm really starting to get into this now. Why are people voting for anypony other than Rainbow Dash?
    I get that people vote something other than Rainbow Dash, but I don't get it why it's Pinkie Pie they are voting.
  • Okay, so I'm really starting to get into this now. Why are people voting for anypony other than Rainbow Dash?
    Pity?
  • Not only is Flutterguy version funnier, it's better and clearly the song was meant for Flutterguy, story reasons needed the Pinkie Pie version there also.
    Oh, clearly.
  • Okay, so I'm really starting to get into this now. Why are people voting for anypony other than Rainbow Dash?
    Because Rainbow Dash is a dick, and Fluttershy is more adorable.
  • Not only is Flutterguy version funnier, it's better and clearly the song was meant for Flutterguy, story reasons needed the Pinkie Pie version there also.
    Oh, clearly.
    But when I think about it. I quite liked how that episode showed that Pinkie Pies songs aren't just something random, that comes from somewhere, but they are result of thinking, trying and working on the song.
  • Not only is Flutterguy version funnier, it's better and clearly the song was meant for Flutterguy, story reasons needed the Pinkie Pie version there also.
    Oh, clearly.
    But when I think about it. I quite liked how that episode showed that Pinkie Pies songs aren't just something random, that comes from somewhere, but they are result of thinking, trying and working on the song.
    And if Pinkie Pie didn't make those cute eyes at Flutterguy, we wouldn't of heard it again. Though, that episode is one of the best ones just because of all the jokes. I re-watched it again recently, and I was laughing because Flutterguy's scream sounded so different even when loud.

    Pinkie Pie works the best for me because she's both funny, random, AND adorable.
  • Pinkie Pie works the best for me because she's both funny, random, AND adorable.
    Fluttershy is even more adorable, also cute and good character.
  • I maintain that Pinkie Pie is just trolling everyone.

    Could Fluttershy stare down Princess Celestia?
  • I maintain that Pinkie Pie is just trolling everyone.
    Which is why she's clearly the best.
  • Could Fluttershy stare down Princess Celestia?
    Yes, but Celestia wouldn't look her in the eye.
  • Could Fluttershy stare down Princess Celestia?
    Yes, but Celestia wouldn't look her in the eye.
    Fluttershy's stare would work on Celestia, but there's a catch. As soon as she tried to do it, she would instinctively bow her head. Celestia would know what was going down,and would impale Fluttershy with her gigantic horn.
  • impale Fluttershy with her gigantic horn.
    Is that what they're calling it these days?
  • I know I'm a bit late to the party but after debating between Fluttershy and Rainbow Dash, I ultimately picked Fluttershy. Honestly, Flutterguy was hilarious.
  • edited March 2011
    This poll should be changed to "Which pony is the best not counting RainbowDash".

    Without a doubt, Pinkie Pie is the dark horse in the group, but Big Macintosh and Twilight are a close second after Rainbow.

    Derpy's time will come!
    Post edited by Casa Vino on
  • Hmm. Late to the party, and to be honest its going to be all rainbow dash or pinkie/flutter pony from now on..

    BUT...rarity for me!! Always will be!
  • This poll should be changed to "Which pony is the best not counting RainbowDash".

    Amen.

    I don't want Rainbow Dash to be my favorite pony, because it's too obvious. But she is. I can't help it.

    In my household, we've been picking favorites at three levels: Primary (not counting RD), Secondary, and Tertiary Ponies, with categories based on amount of screen time. For example, mine would be Pinkie Pie, Granny Smith, and DJ Pon-3.
  • For example, mine would be Pinkie Pie, Granny Smith, and DJ Pon-3.
    My best guess is Fluttershy, Big Macintosh, and Derpy Hooves, but I'm not sure.
  • Easy:

    Primary: Pinkie Pie
    Secondary: Fluttershy
    Tertiary: Apple Bloom
  • edited March 2011
    Fluttershy
    Fluttershy
    Fluttershy.

    Alternatively,
    Fluttershy
    Big Mac
    Doctor Whooves
    Post edited by Linkigi(Link-ee-jee) on
Sign In or Register to comment.