When did "magic: the gathering" jump the shark?
... and why?
I've heard Rym and Scott mentioning a couple of times, that they stopped playing magic a long time ago (don´t remember which episode they said it, and which edition they stopped.) And I noticed there are a lot of ex-magic-players that show nostalgia towards old editions, but feel magic jumped the shark at some point.
I would like to know the different editions people stopped playing magic, and why. Especially if you are someone who cares about game design. I feel that the concept of magic changes all the time, even though the rules are relatively the same with every edition change.