Yeah, that's basically an issue of corporeal punishment. Like Rym, I'd agree that instances where a woman could bear a child without the man's implicit consent (N.b.: not using protection is implicit consent for a woman to bear your child) would render said woman ineligible for child support. However, I'd hasten to add that said "implicit consent" is very hazy w/r/t the law even concerning the physical act of sex, let alone the biologic aftermath.
Also, Got to drive one of the New Toyota GT86s today. Fuck me that's a fun little machine. If I had the cash, I'd probably buy one. And they're not that expensive...
But in return, she couldn't demand child care from him.
Child care is for the child, not the woman.
What they should do is take custody away from her immediately while you stick her in prison. If there is anyone in the world who does not deserve to be raising a child...
Yeah, that's basically an issue of corporeal punishment. Like Rym, I'd agree that instances where a woman could bear a child without the man's implicit consent (N.b.: not using protection is implicit consent for a woman to bear your child) would render said woman ineligible for child support. However, I'd hasten to add that said "implicit consent" is very hazy w/r/t the law even concerning the physical act of sex, let alone the biologic aftermath.
If we're talking about how things ought to be, I'd say that the standard should be one of explicit consent.
That said, in order to preserve genuine choice while protecting children, such a system would probably be one where we would want child support to be paid for by the state should the mother unilaterally decide to carry the pregnancy to term.
Absent state-paid support, it makes sense for the state to impose on someone for child support for the sake of the child, and the biological father is in most circumstances the logical choice (with some exceptions, such as sperm donors).
What they should do is take custody away from her immediately while you stick her in prison. If there is anyone in the world who does not deserve to be raising a child...
No, I don't think that is sufficient evidence of parental unfitness. Perhaps there is an argument to be made for much more restrictive criteria as to what constitutes a fit parent, but that is not an issue to be taken lightly.
If we're talking about how things ought to be, I'd say that the standard should be one of explicit consent.
More specifically, how about a system where the father has no paternal rights and no paternal obligations unless he bilaterally agrees with the mother?
I don't think one should make sweeping generalizations like that unless the persons action/belief directly targets the person in question (ie Nazis are unfit rabis, though that would make an awesome sitcom). Any generic rapist shouldn't be a parent, but there do exist rapists who are capable of being good parents.
Comments
Anyway:
But in return, she couldn't demand child care from him.
Also, Got to drive one of the New Toyota GT86s today. Fuck me that's a fun little machine. If I had the cash, I'd probably buy one. And they're not that expensive...
What they should do is take custody away from her immediately while you stick her in prison. If there is anyone in the world who does not deserve to be raising a child...
That said, in order to preserve genuine choice while protecting children, such a system would probably be one where we would want child support to be paid for by the state should the mother unilaterally decide to carry the pregnancy to term.
Absent state-paid support, it makes sense for the state to impose on someone for child support for the sake of the child, and the biological father is in most circumstances the logical choice (with some exceptions, such as sperm donors). No, I don't think that is sufficient evidence of parental unfitness. Perhaps there is an argument to be made for much more restrictive criteria as to what constitutes a fit parent, but that is not an issue to be taken lightly.
moar
Wildly irresponsible, yes, but awesome.
This is the funniest thing I have ever seen.